Tuesday, October 17, 2006

Opinion about Real Estate professionalism

Here is one opinion about real estate proffesionalism. Some what Mr. Marguleas says makes sense, much does not.
Anthony Marguleas, broker and owner of high-end realty firm Amalfi Estates in Los Angeles, thinks the industry shouldn't be spitting out low-producing agents. Instead, it should be harder to become one.

Marguleas researched the number of hours it takes to become a licensed real estate agent, which varies by state. In California, he says, getting a license calls for a 45-hour class. Nationwide, the requirements range from a low of 24 hours in Massachusetts to a high of 120 hours in Ohio, according to ARELLO. He says it takes 9,000 hours to become a doctor and 1,600 hours to become a cosmetologist.

"To dye someone's hair it takes 20 times more studying than to help someone sell the largest investment of their life," he says.

"Real estate agents typically get ranked right around used-car salesmen. The bar is so low to get a real estate license," says Marguleas, who operates in a high-end market in Pacific Palisades, Calif., and has been in the real estate business for 15 years. "I would love to make it as hard as it is to become a doctor or lawyer to raise the professionalism. So many people who do this are part-time and not very knowledgeable about what they're doing. It's why consumers have such a poor image of real estate agents."

How can real estate agents as a group garner more public respect when they are lead by discredited shills like David Lereah? (that was a rhetorical question) Also, I don't agree that it should be as hard to become a real estate agent as it is to become a doctor or lawyer.

16 comments:

  1. "To dye someone's hair it takes 20 times more studying than to help someone sell the largest investment of their life," he says.

    +++++++++++++++++++++++++++

    i can't get past this statment!!!

    this guy is a retard cause as we all know RE has not one thing to do with investing....just ask Lance.

    it must drive Lance crazy when he hears people in the RE business mislead buyers into thinking this.

    i know Lance wants to do away with the nanny state (so do i as i should be able to smoke snort anything i want or even buy sex cause i'm only hurting myself....just like Lance said) so this guy should be brought up on some sort of charges to imply that buying or selling a home is an invesment.

    just sayin.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Personally, I'd rather not create a monopoly for real estate agents as we already have for doctors, lawyers, and stock brokers ... Forcing up real estate transaction costs even higher than they already are. Good agents will prosper (in any market) and bad agents soon find themselves not making enough to live on .. in any market other than a rapidly rising one as we recently experienced. And eventually, a rapidly rising markets end, and only "good agents" survive. But hey, even these bad agents served their purpose. They helped process the large number of transactions that only the otherwise licensed realtors would have been handed were licensing requirements raised. This would allow these monopolistic real estate agents to NOT process all transactions and to charge more for those they did. And when all is said and done, in the kind of market we just had, how could you really have a bad agent? Anything on the market sold (i.e., few marketing skills were needed) and with only a limited supply of properties for sale, even a pleatora of better qualified realtors wouldn't have created more houses to be sold. Of course, I am assuming that one doesn't really expect a real estate agent to be doing anything more than leading his/her buyer or seller through the sales process ... Real Estate agents aren't out there to be giving financial/investment advice ... And anyone ignorant enough to depend on a real estate agent for financing and investment decision making deserves whatever they get out of it. I wouldn't go to a real estate agent for financing or investment advice any more than I would go to a priest for marital advice. You go to these folks to get your transaction done ... That's it. And it doesn't take a Phd to properly and legally process a transaction.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I wouldn't go to a real estate agent for financing or investment advice any more than I would go to a priest for marital advice.


    :lol:

    that is really funny cause being Catholic like i am that is EXACTLY what they make you do BEFORE the church will marry you.

    of course that didn't do me or her any good.

    and yet daily in almost every RE article we read and hear online every single person (except the ultimate bubble head Lance) treats RE as an investment.

    so either every other person i ever talked to reguarding RE is wrong Lance or you are???

    you pick.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Alert the media, I agree with lance.

    ReplyDelete
  5. A monopoly for doctors? lance, have you lost your damn mind? I am THANKFUL for the difficulty it takes for a person to obtain a medical license! May that monopoly continue.

    ReplyDelete
  6. good lord. Lance, you have to stop making statements that I agree with. It's scaring me.

    oh except technically it's not a monopoly (of lawyers, doctors, etc), rather it's an oligopoly. Monopoly implies just one entity (seller).

    ReplyDelete
  7. I wish doctors would make more money. I want only the brightest people to become doctors. My health care is very important. I pray every day we don't get universal health care, it would be the down fall to the us medical system. When the big money leaves a profession, the intelligent people leave the profession. Just look at teachers. They dont make a lot of money, and there major is the "I dropped out of the XXX program and became a teacher" major. All of the dropouts in college go into elementary ed.

    ReplyDelete
  8. If you think licensing is good for consumers, ask yourself: Why is a real estate firm owner proposing it?

    The answer: It's bad for consumers, but good for real estate agents, because stricter licensing reduces competition among real estate agents. It reduces competition by creating barriers to entry into the profession.

    It's good old supply and demand: reduce the number of real estate agents and you increase the costs that consumers have to pay.

    Lance is usually wrong, but on this issue he is right. For more on how some professions use licensing to hurt consumers, I strongly recommend reading Capitalism and Freedom by Nobel Prize-winning economist Milton Friedman.

    ReplyDelete
  9. lance and james, that was some of the most refreshing commentary I've read on this blog.

    Professional licensing should be voluntary. As a consumer, I should be free to choose between a real estate agent who has degrees in finance and law, and one who has a GED and enough credit hours at the community college to be eligible to take the state real estate license exam. As it is, I’m stuck with the latter.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Let's remember that it is the state government that requires a person to get a license to perform real estate transactions on behalf of others.

    And it is also the government that sets the hours and criteria that one has to satisfy in order to take the licensee test.

    All realtors learn in those hours is how to pass the exam.

    Brokers do not need to make these kinds of demands on licensee's. Instead they could just not allow the licensee to hand their license in their brokerage.

    It is a concern among realtors of level of quality service providers there happen to be in any given market. It is up to the consumer to not choose sub-standard representation.

    I'm sure this isn't a very friendly place to realtors around here, but I'm going to say that there is a revolution coming in the realtor world. The current broker/agent model will likely go down in flames, data sharing will change, and other business models will change.

    And soon... I hope.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Laughable. Why should we ever compare real estate agents to attorneys or doctors? RE agents are merely talking heads in a suit -- a lot like a used-car salesman. If you want to straighten up the realtor's image, then educate the public to the myriad of financial scams that realtors perpetuate on the American public on a daily basis, and enact laws that closely regulate inflated costs of lending, title insurance and fees. Furthermore, don't let realtors provide financial advice or forward looking statements on the housing market. Don't let them recommend or work in cahoots with a mortgage broker. Don't let them recommend title insurance or receive kickbacks from title insurance houses or mortgage brokers. Separate and isolate the housing appraisal industry from the reaches of the real estate agent and mortgage broker. And finally, open the MLS to everyone. If we remove all the scams that the realtor plays on the American homeowner, and consequentially reduce their take from our pockets, we won't be seeing so many in the field. Ipso facto.

    ReplyDelete
  12. "To dye someone's hair it takes 20 times more studying than to help someone sell the largest investment of their life,"

    Actually it's much more than about hair dyes. The chemicals used in hair perms are dangerous and have the potential to do serious physical harm if used improperly. In fact many beauty supply shops won't sell you these chemicals without a valid cosmetologist license. Cosmetologists also have to be trained in the proper sterlization of their tools to prevent infections and the possible spread of diseases/parasites.

    Marguleas' statement is pretty insulting and shows an ignorance about the cosmetology profession. When was the last time a person's immediate health was jeopardized by a real estate agent?

    ReplyDelete
  13. For the real bob --

    Actually the biggest factor in the declining quality of ed school graduates is that smart women have so many other career options available to them now. I know legions of brilliant women in their 70s and older who had to choose: teacher or nurse?

    ReplyDelete
  14. quietann, excellent point. But, if they started offering a 150k a year for teachers, you would see alot more talent entering the field. Of course, you would have to get rid of the socialist union that exists for teachers before anything could happen there!

    ReplyDelete
  15. actually to become a doctor it took me 4 years of college + 4 Years of medical school + 3 years or residency.
    total hours at 40 Hrs/wk x 8 years (college and med school) + 80 hrs/wk x 3 years internship/residency
    =27360 hrs and trust me that is definitely underestimated
    + jefferson med school in philly cost me 25K a year x 4 = 100K debt not including college.
    starting salary for primary care = 95K

    ReplyDelete
  16. Hello,

    I recently published an article on mortgage loans, tips on how to make them work for you and other forms of mortgage financials – here is a quote from it, in case you are interested:

    Smell a Good Deal for a Real Estate – Try to discover a property that has already got some equity in it, when you purchase it. Equity represents the value of a real estate, a property after you have paid any mortgage or other charges relating to it.

    Try to Get a Second Mortgage on the Real Estate – You could try to be more creative and ask the seller whether he would be willing to have a second mortgage on that home. Thus you could set up an agreement with the seller through which you will have to pay monthly an approximate sum of $200, for instance, on $15,000 of the price of the real estate (plus or including the interest rate), for the second mortgage.

    Save Some Money to Pay in Advance – Some lenders might give you a full credit if you come with at least a small percentage of the sum. This would grant you supplementary points for getting the credit and would also lower the interest rate – e key point of any mortgage refinance program.

    Don’t Give up, Go Further – don’t trust the first broker who tells you that there is no hope for you. You will finally find someone who could offer a viable solution, just keep asking and searching. An alternative is to apply online to mortgage services. Thus your application would be seen by more lenders and you might get more offers to analyze your solvency.

    Improve Your Present Credit Score – by not applying to credit cards, auto loans or other loans, if possible. Too many inquiries would also affect credit scores. Another important thing you should do to improve your credit scores is to acquit your current duties and payments on time.

    If you feel this helps, please drop by my website for additional information, such as how to refinance a second mortgage or additional resources on mortgage rates.

    Regards,

    Michael

    ReplyDelete